Governor Monday Okpebholo’s suspension of chairmen and vice-chairmen across Edo State’s 18 local government areas has triggered a constitutional crisis.

The action, based on allegations of insubordination and failure to submit financial reports, has drawn sharp criticism, with legal experts citing a landmark Supreme Court ruling affirming local government autonomy.

Barr. Andrew Emwanta, a member of the Administrative Panel of Inquiry established by the governor, defended the suspensions, arguing that they align with constitutional provisions. 

Speaking on Channels Television, Emwanta stated, “The Constitution has placed local governments under state control. Financial autonomy ensures access to funds but does not strip state governments of oversight responsibilities. The Supreme Court cannot amend the Constitution; Section 7 remains intact.”

However, the Supreme Court’s July 11 judgment underscores that state governments lack the authority to dissolve or interfere in democratically elected local councils.

Chief Lateef Olasunkanmi Fagbemi, SAN, the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF), called the suspensions illegal.

“Under the present dispensation, governors have no right to remove local government chairmen. That power lies solely with the legislative houses of the councils,” Fagbemi affirmed.

ALGON reacts

The Association of Local Governments of Nigeria (ALGON) condemned the suspensions as an abuse of power and a violation of due process.

“This move contradicts the Supreme Court’s judgment and undermines local government autonomy,” ALGON’s statement read, urging the reversal of the decision.

Political analysts warn that the unfolding controversy could escalate into a constitutional showdown.

“This crisis tests not only the relationship between state and local governments but also the judiciary’s authority in upholding constitutional provisions,” one analyst noted.

Observers highlight the political implications, as President Tinubu has been a vocal advocate for local government autonomy.

The involvement of a governor from Tinubu’s party, in apparent defiance of this stance, raises questions about internal party alignment.

With ALGON calling for federal intervention and the Edo State Government resolute, the stage is set for a significant legal and political confrontation.

All eyes now turn to the judiciary and Tinubu’s administration to mediate this landmark dispute.